Al Arabiya: Mubarak’s new mouthpiece?

When watching Al Arabiya’s coverage lately, one gets the feeling that the station’s executives recently met with Mubarak’s PR team and asked, “what can we do for you?”
The Saudi-owned 24 hour news network seemed to be covering events rather objectively at the start of the demonstrations, but over the last couple of days it has portrayed the protestors as wildly violent, while airing a series of promotional videos that resemble state-produced propaganda. The most egregious of these is a slide show clip that has been running all day long during commercial breaks. In it, we hear Mubarak’s voice asking Egyptians to preserve stability and end chaos, played over slides of violent images:

And some glorifying the state’s security services:

The overall tone is a nationalist one, closing with images of flag waiving as Mubarak’s deep voice sounds a note of salvation and hope:

The promo video ends with the Al Arabiya slogan: “To know more”, as if to say Mubarak’s side of the story has been ignored, despite the fact that he’s been in power for decades.

Another powerful montage opens every Al Arabiya report on Egypt, again using images of violence to depict the protestors as dangerous and harmful to the country’s future. The piece zooms through tire burning and screaming protestors to focus in on a bandit-like character with menacing eyes:

The piece ends on with the graphic, “Crisis in Egypt”:

Indeed Al Arabiya’s anchors have regularly repeated the words ‘chaos’ and ‘destruction’ in describing events, echoing the soundbites of pro-Mubarak citizens, which are featured heavily in the coverage. A report on a relatively small pro-Mubarak rally was played at least five times this evening:

Other Al Arabiya reports seem to valorize the police, with images of citizens shaking hands with officers:
And fact boxes noting their vast–and perhaps intimidating– numbers:

Al Arabiya is also devoting a lot of time to the economic cost of the protests, detailing losses in the hotel and tourism industry, again depicting the protest and the protestors as harmful.

Al Jazeera, on the other hand, paints a vastly different image of the demonstrations with guests and reporters touting their participants as brave, patriotic, brotherly and educated. Even American broadcasters have picked up on this theme, with NBC running a report last night about Egyptians volunteering to direct traffic and pick up garbage around their city. Asked why she was volunteering, one young protestor replied “because I love my country and I have to take care of it.”
As I post this, Al Jazeera is now airing an investigative documentary it produced a few years ago documenting the routine use of torture by Mubarak’s security services–a film that landed the director in jail. Al Jazeera’s reputation for challenging authority rather than pleasing it, is undoubtedly a major reason why it continues to lead Al Arabiya and others in the ratings.
  1. WOW your anti Hariri, Pro Jazeera, Anti Arabia slant has simply shown your true colors. you used to be unbiased, but now Im sorry I cant read your drivel anymore. Are you even listening to what the religious preachers that aljazeera has on the air CONSTANTLY are saying?? Im sorry but just looking at pictures is not enough Habib, you have to listen to what is being said! and yes the situation in Egypt has a cost, why the fuck shouldnt people be aware what it is, should the US be the only ones that know what is happening on day to day basis and its impact that it will have on the Egyptians for years to come. Seriously, I used to look at you for news now if i want propaganda I know where to go

  2. Thanks for your interest Anon and I’m sorry you were so angered by this post. My hope is that the comments section can be a place for dialogue and I wish yours were a bit less emotional and a bit more specific. At any rate I will address them.

    First, you say that I’m very “pro Jazeera” but in reality I’ve taken a critical look at almost all the Arab and American media I follow including Al Jazeera. See “Al Jazeera: Agenda Setting or TV setting” as a recent example:

    Second, you say I have ignored the comments of preachers on speaking on air “constantly” on Al Jazeera. Frankly I have been watching Al Jazeera for days now and have not seen any preachers on air, save one telephone call-in from one who expressed support for the protesters. Perhaps I have missed the episode you are talking about but there is certainly not a “constant” presence of preachers on air– or was that rhetorical exaggeration on your part? At any rate, do enlighten my readers and I as to what preachers have been saying and when they appeared, and their names if possible. It might make for an interesting discussion.

    Finally and above all this post was about Al Arabiya, not Al Jazeera and not Hariri. Do you have any comments about my characterization of Al Arabiya’s coverage? You have only addressed a minor point on the question of tourism losses, which I look at as one aspect in the overall package of coverage and in-house clips, which in my view paints the protesters as dark and destructive. Do you disagree with that?

    And what is the connection to Hariri here? He is not mentioned anywhere in this post. Are you referring to a previous post when I was nearly assaulted by his supporters? If so, please let me know what bothers you about that testimony and please be specific so that we can have a discussion, which could be more productive (for both of us) than a one-sided tirade.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like
Read More

Where the magic happens

Beirut Municipality -circa 2012 Apart from the Salame women (cousins?), I’m guessing the rest of the sprawling, half-block…
Read More

Back with a vengence

Future Television has just begun broadcasting again after several days of being shut down by opposition militants. Here,…